Sexuality and Relationships Education for people with Down syndrome
Amanda Wood
All children and young people should be entitled to good quality sex and
relationships education that will allow them to develop the qualities,
attitudes, skills and knowledge to develop into healthy, happy and fulfilled
adults
Wood A. Sexuality and Relationships Education for people with Down syndrome. Down Syndrome News and Update. 2004;4(2);42-51.
doi:10.3104/practice.330
This article describes why Sexuality and Relationships Education (SRE) as
part of the school curriculum is especially important for individuals with Down
syndrome and how parents and professionals can work together to ensure that it
is delivered effectively.
For decades around the world, and to this day in some countries, people with
Down syndrome have lived their lives in institutions, away from their families
and communities, their parents told at birth that this was the best option for
them. How different the outlook is today, in the light of research that has
changed attitudes and determined legislation, policies and practice ensuring
that people with Down syndrome have the right to education, employment, and
equal access to health and social care.
However, researching this article has highlighted an injustice that could have
the effect of placing people with Down syndrome back in a lonely and isolated
world, not necessarily behind closed doors but potentially, in the heart of
their communities. In the introduction to her book Couples with intellectual
disabilities talk about living and loving, Karin Melberg Schwier describes how
difficult it can be for some parents and professionals to allow children with
Down syndrome to grow into adults, 'whole adults' that is, adults who have adult
relationships.[1]
In some instances, anxieties about abuse, exploitation, pregnancy and sexually
transmitted infections have overtaken our appreciation that firstly, personal
relationships do not always lead to sexual intercourse and secondly that the
positive aspects of sexuality and affection are natural, healthy expressions of
our humanity, whether or not we have an intellectual disability. Melburg Schwier
describes how our fears may become exaggerated to such an extent that we deny
young people with disabilities the right to grow into adults who are able and
allowed to have relationships that provide companionship, conversation, trust,
love and an appreciation of who they are. Her opening foreword makes poignant
reading, as one realises that, in some cases, over-protection and a lack of
opportunity to build self-esteem, personal and social skills may deny a person
the right to share their life with someone else; a person who is "for
themselves, not someone paid to be there, not someone who will disappear in the
next wave of staff turnover, someone other than their parents and family".[1:
p.26]
As Fanstone and Katrak state in their handbook for staff "to deny that a person
with a learning disability is a sexual being is to treat them less fully as a
person".[6:p.3] They go on to say that this is an example of discrimination and
as such is "not only an ethical but a professional practice issue." They too
suggest that fear may inhibit some professionals from participating in sexuality
and relationships work with their clients. It is important to acknowledge that
fears about the vulnerability of people with learning disabilities to sexual
abuse are not unjustified (see Box 1: 'Myths and controversies'). It is,
therefore, crucial to find a balance between upholding the basic human right to
understand, enjoy and express one's sexuality but also to be protected from
unwanted pregnancy, sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, and sexual
abuse.
Box 1: Myths and controversies
A number of myths abound regarding people with Down syndrome and sexuality:
- The holy innocent – Some cultures and religions regard people with Down
syndrome as 'holy innocents', they are not sexual beings and do not require any
education in such matters
- The eternal child – Some people believe that children with Down syndrome
remain child-like forever and as such are asexual
- Over-sexed – Some people believe that people with learning disabilities are
over-sexed; that they have increased sexual energy and desire and therefore may
be unable to control themselves
X These myths are socially constructed by people without Down syndrome and may
serve a number of functions, e.g. the latter is likely to have been constructed
at a time when most people with intellectual disabilities lived in single-sex
institutions with little or no stimulation of any kind; it could be used to
legitimise sexual abuse by staff and/or sterilisation as a means of social
control
- Fertility – Some people believe that men with Down syndrome are infertile and
that women with Down syndrome have an increased risk of conceiving infants with
genetic abnormalities
X These beliefs may in part be true, however, there is extremely limited
research in these areas; the research that exists is also based on generations
from an age when most adults with Down syndrome were living in institutions,
under abnormal circumstances. There are documented cases of men with Down
syndrome who have fathered children although there are many more documented
cases of women with Down syndrome who have given birth. Please see Melberg
Schwier and Hingsburger (2000) for a review of current knowledge in this
area.[2]
Reality Check
People with Down syndrome
- go through puberty at roughly the same chronological age as their typically
developing peers and experience the same body changes
- experience the full range of human emotions and desires including the desire
for intimacy and sexual contact
- are likely to vary as widely as their typically developing peers with regard
to their 'sex drives'
Sexual abuse and people with intellectual disabilities
- Relative risk of abuse may be as much as four times higher for people with
disabilities compared with the rest of the population, with people with learning
disabilities at the highest risk[3]
Sexually transmitted infections including HIV
- HIV is a real issue for everyone, including people with intellectual
disabilities; it has been suggested that the infection rate in this group is as
high as the infection rate in the most rapidly increasing populations in the
general population, i.e. perinatally infected infants and heterosexual adults
who have contracted the infection through sexual intercourse[4]
What do we mean by sexuality and sex and relationships education?
Sexuality relates to our understanding of what it means physically,
psychologically and culturally to be male or female. It includes an awareness of
our feelings, needs and desires and develops gradually across the lifespan with
our changing life experiences. As we mature physically and developmentally, we
will develop a range of strategies to express and fulfil these changing
feelings, needs and desires. Sexuality can be said to be an important component
of our self-concept and as such, will affect our interactions with others, our
behaviour and our life-style choices. As one comes to see how our sexuality
develops across time, it is easy to see that we will have differing needs for
sex and relationships education at different points across the lifespan, from
infancy, through childhood, adolescence and on into adulthood.
In the UK, sex and relationships education is described as a process of
"life-long learning about physical, moral and emotional development. It is about
the understanding of the importance of marriage for family life, stable and
loving relationships, respect, love and care. It is also about the teaching of
sex, sexuality, and sexual health."[7] Effective sex and relationships education
will pay equal attention to the development of attitudes (e.g. an appreciation
of difference; tolerance and respect, openness), skills (e.g. negotiation,
problem solving, friendship, communication, assertiveness, personal care) and
knowledge (e.g. about puberty, reproduction, sexually transmitted infections).
Box 2 provides an overview of some of the different topics that you
might expect a child to learn about over the years. Below, we discuss the
significance of these topic areas for children with Down syndrome and how
parents and schools can work together to provide appropriate teaching and
learning experiences, differentiated to the individual child's needs and his or
her learning style.
These topic areas are likely to be taught both at home and at school. Please see
the Department of Education and Skills (DfES) Sex and Relationships Education
Guidance (2000)[7] for details of which areas are taught as part of the
compulsory UK Science National Curriculum and at which key stages and which
parts are part of the Personal Social and Health Education (PSHE) and
Citizenship Frameworks.
Box 2: Attitudes, skills and knowledge that may be covered in SRE
- Developing a positive attitude towards self and others including developing
self-concept and self-esteem
- Developing effective communication skills including elements of non-verbal
communication such as personal space and body language
- Public and private behaviour, modesty and privacy
- Vocabulary to discuss feelings and the body
- Places that are safe and unsafe to play
- Who to talk to and ask for help or support
- Relationship; family, friends, sexual partners, work colleagues
- Bullying; why it can happen and how to get help
- Differences between males and females
- How we change as we grow up; they need to be prepared for puberty
- How to look after their bodies; personal hygiene and health screening
- Appropriate and inappropriate touch of self and others
- The importance of consent to touch another person's body or have someone touch
you; how to keep yourself safe and be assertive
- Reproduction and how to prevent pregnancy
- Sexually transmitted infections and how they can be prevented
Creating positive messages from the start; how can parents get the ball rolling?
The ability to love and feel loved, to keep safe and know how to protect to
oneself physically and emotionally stems from our self-esteem; that is our
understanding and knowledge about ourselves and our sense of worth. We build
this knowledge from an early age and therefore our early experiences in the home
will shape our development and the opportunities that may be open to us
throughout our lives. This means that the issues relating to personal
relationships and sexuality are not constrained only to childhood and the
teenage years. In fact, parents are starting to build the foundations for their
child's positive transition into adult life right from the start.
[8] Ryan
underlines this by saying "we are already giving a positive sexuality message by
regarding our children as important people, by having high expectations, by
nurturing and caring for them, and teaching them to look after their bodies".[9] Melburg Schwier and Hingsburger echo these themes commenting that "to begin an
education about sexuality, self-hood, value and worth" a child requires the
following underpinning knowledge: "I am loved. I am welcome here. My body is
mine".[2, p.26] Parents are likely to start to develop this knowledge in their
children with and without Down syndrome from a very early age.
As infants with Down syndrome progress into childhood, parents are, in fact,
likely to remain the primary source of information about sexuality for their
children with Down syndrome, who may have fewer opportunities to observe,
develop and practice social skills, and be less able to access information
through written materials or through indirect means such as unstructured
discussion with peers.[8] However, it is important to note that formal education
also plays an important role and therefore, parents need not feel alone in
tackling these issues. Some parents may fear that discussion of the body, sex
and 'where babies come from' may encourage sexual experimentation however,
research suggests that in typical development, young people who have been raised
in families where sex and personal relationships have been discussed as part of
everyday life, in an emotionally open and honest household, are more likely to
delay the onset of sexual activity and are more likely to use contraception.[10]
The next section discusses some of the specific topic areas drawn from
Box 2 in
the context of teaching children with Down syndrome. These areas are likely to
make up part of the child's education within school but may also be supported
through activities at home. Before looking at these topic areas, however, let us
briefly examine the role of formal education in delivering sex and relationships
education in the UK and describe some general teaching and learning principles,
which are relevant to differentiating the curriculum for pupils with Down
syndrome.
The role of schools in the delivery of sex and relationships education (SRE)
In the UK, schools are legally obliged under The Learning and Skills Act (2000)
to provide sex and relationships education to all pupils. They are also obliged
to have an SRE policy, which is available to parents and for inspection. This
legislation is supported by the Sex and Relationship Education Guidance (2000)
which explains that SRE should be 'firmly rooted within the framework for PSHE
(Personal Social and Health Education) and the National Curriculum (1999). The
guidance document aims to clarify what schools are expected to deliver by law,
help staff to develop an SRE policy in liaison with parents, pupils, teachers,
governors and the wider community, describe good practice in terms of teaching
practice and highlight some of the sensitive issues that may raised through the
delivery of SRE.[7]
Box 3: Entitlements for all children and young people
Children and young people, regardless of disability, should be entitled to sex
and relationships education which:
- Enables them to make responsible and well-informed decisions
- Helps them to develop the necessary skills and understanding to live
confident, happy and healthy lives, with as greater degree of independence as
possible
- Fosters acceptance of diversity and values marriage and stable, loving
relationships as the building blocks of community and society
- Prevents and removes prejudice and fosters respect for self and others
Why is sex and relationships education particularly important for people of all
ages with Down syndrome?
- They are less likely to learn effectively from indirect sources
- They may be at greater risk of developing low self esteem and SRE may be
helpful in raising this
- Opportunities to learn from social situations may be more limited
- Risk of abuse and exploitation is greater for people with intellectual
disabilities than their typically developing peers
The Guidance also outlines The National Healthy School Standard, which was
introduced in 1999 to support the new PSHE framework. The Standard suggests that
the most effective SRE programmes identify "learning outcomes, appropriate to
pupils' age, ability, gender and level of maturity" based on assessment of
pupils' individual needs. The programme should also take account of the views of
parents and caregivers and the pupils themselves.
These points are particularly salient to the provision of a differentiated
programme of study for pupils with Down syndrome. The DfES guidance clearly
states that "mainstream schools and special schools have a duty to ensure that
children with special educational needs and learning difficulties are properly
included in sex and relationships education" and that "teachers may find that
they have to be more explicit and plan their work in different ways in order to
meet individual needs of children with special education needs or learning
difficulties". Finally, it clearly states that pupils should not be "withdrawn
from health education so that they can catch up on National Curriculum
subjects". [7:p.12]
Teachers and other professionals, including for example, youth workers, need to
work collaboratively with parents in order to develop programmes of study that
suit the individual pupils needs. As noted in the introduction, although most
parents want schools to be involved in the provision of SRE, some parents of
children with disabilities may be anxious about their child engaging in sex and
relationships education for a variety of reasons. Professionals will need to
work sensitively to help these parents to appreciate the importance of this area
of the curriculum. Staff should use the school's SRE policy to guide them in
their communication with parents about the importance of inclusion in sex and
relationships education as part of the wider curriculum.
Having discussed the possible anxieties of parents with regard to tackling sex
and relationships issues with their children, we should return to the point made
in the introduction, that some professionals may also be anxious or indeed
fearful of addressing the issues with their pupils or clients, especially when
they have learning disabilities. This implies that staff need adequate training
and support in this area. By 2006, secondary schools will be required by the
Teenage Pregnancy Strategy to have at least one member of staff who has received
accredited training in PSHE. In the meantime, local curriculum development
groups made up of representatives from a number of local primary and secondary
schools can be helpful sources of good practice and resources for students with
learning disabilities. Also, Local Education Authorities (LEAs) will have
specialist PSHE advisory services who may be able to help, whilst The Sex
Education Forum which is part of the National Children's Bureau provide a wealth
of detailed fact sheets available to download at from www.ncb.org.uk/sef . They
also supply a comprehensive list of resources that are appropriate for teaching
SRE to children and young people with learning disabilities.
Effective teaching strategies
Box 4 summarises a number of recommended teaching strategies for delivery of
effective sex and relationships education to typically developing pupils. It is
interesting to note that many of the techniques listed are comparable with the
generally recommended strategies for differentiating any subject for a learner
with Down syndrome. This supports the idea that adapting teaching strategies to
suit the needs of a pupil with Down syndrome in a mainstream class will in fact
be beneficial for many of his or her fellow pupils.
Box 4: Effective teaching strategies
[12]
- Drama and role play
- Discussion of case studies/real-life scenarios: possibly from TV or magazine
photo-stories
- Story-telling, poems and songs
- Use of puppets and dolls (www.me-and-us.com supply anatomically correct dolls
for SRE teaching)
- Pictures and story-boards
- Videos and photographs: including TV adverts, clips from soap operas
- Art activities including collage and poster making
- Games
There are several keys to differentiation for children with Down syndrome and
these are as important for teaching about sex and relationships as any other
topic area. Firstly, it is important to ensure that the child is motivated to
learn about the particular topic by carefully choosing teaching strategies that
the child enjoys and which have previously been successful. Making the
information feel familiar and grounded in the child's experiences will be
important and help the child to use existing knowledge to understand more
advanced concepts. Staff could choose characters from the child's favourite
books or TV programmes and make up new stories raising various issues. For
example, for a child who is using the Oxford Reading Tree books, one could cut
out pictures of Mum and Biff and make up a story about when Biff starts her
periods using language which is suited to the child's level of comprehension but
introducing some new vocabulary and ideas. With any new information taught
through reading activities, it is important however, to build in activities to
ensure that the child understands what he or she has read, i.e. through acting
out the information with puppets, dolls or in role-play or through re-ordering
sentences or retelling the story.
Children with Down syndrome are typically 'visual learners'; that is they learn
and retain more from visual sources of information than from listening. Picture
libraries available online or on CD Roms make it possible to download and print
all sorts of images, which may be helpful in supporting vocabulary work; see for
example Picture Yourself at www.me-and-us.co.uk and the Sexual Awareness Resource
Pack from Signalong (see
http://www.signalong.org.uk/wa/publications/index.htm). Please note the author
has not seen either of these resources and therefore, this should not be taken
as a recommendation of their quality.
Depending on the individual child, inclusion within the mainstream teaching of
the subject, using one-to-one support, group-work, differentiated activities and
resources will be enough, however, some children may benefit from extra
one-to-one sessions, possibly from a specially qualified professional such as a
school nurse. It is also likely that themes from the agreed sex and
relationships curriculum can be integrated into a variety of different subject
areas.
Every child will be different and will start with differing needs and prior
knowledge. It is likely that staff will require additional planning time,
including some time with the child's parents in order to develop a programme
that will meet the child's needs. Effective liaison with parents will also mean
that the parents can, if they wish, reinforce new concepts and skills at home
through naturally occurring everyday situations. D'aegher et al (1999) use the
term 'teachable moments' [12:p.16] to describe how helpful it can be to take the
opportunity to discuss certain information as situations arise in everyday life,
e.g. as children or other family members take a bath, whilst sorting various
clothing for the laundry, unpacking items such as toiletries, condoms, sanitary
towels or tampons from the shopping or whilst watching various storylines unfold
in the family's favourite television soaps and dramas. Therefore it is important
that parents are aware of what their child is learning about sex and
relationships at school in order to discuss the issues further at home, as
appropriate opportunities arise.
Shaping socially-acceptable behaviour
Having said that teaching should follow the same methods, as you would use for
teaching any other information, the general principles of behaviour management
can be employed to shape appropriate public and private behaviour and
appropriate use of touch for example. Children learn through observing and
imitating others and through making associations between behaviours and their
consequences. This means that for children to learn socially acceptable
behaviour they need to see other people acting in a socially acceptable way and
they need to be rewarded for their 'good' behaviour and ignored for their less
acceptable behaviour. This implies that it is the other people in the child's
social world who need to carefully monitor their own behaviour and responses in
order to help the child to behave appropriately.
If, for example, you are teaching your child about appropriate physical contact
with other people, it is important that the child is taught how to greet people
in a socially acceptable way, e.g. shake their hand or just say 'hello'. They
will need to see this modeled to them on a regular basis. Many parents comment
on their frustrations as people continue to cuddle their older children and
teenagers with Down syndrome, long after it would be socially acceptable to
cuddle other people's typically developing children. This type of behaviour does
not help the child to learn that it is inappropriate to greet people in this
way. With older children, overt teaching about different types of relationships
such as family, friendship, school/work, sexual partner (boyfriend/girlfriend
and strangers/new people will be helpful for many reasons and part of this work
might involve discussion of how you would greet such people and what sort of
touch is appropriate. One way of doing this might be to look at body outlines
for men and women and select underwear or swimwear from a catalogue to cover up
different areas. This will help children to see which parts of the body are
always private unless you are in a sexual relationship.
A common behaviour, which can cause distress and anxiety for parents and
teachers, is genital touching and masturbation. Firstly, it should be noted that
genital touching is a normal phase of development for young children and is not
associated with the goal-directed behaviour of masturbation, where a person
intentionally seeks sexual gratification. Masturbation should also be viewed as
a natural behaviour for both males and females and therefore one should address
the context in which masturbation occurs, i.e. in public versus in private.
Before discussing methods which might be helpful in preventing or responding to
inappropriate genital touching and/or masturbation, it is important to note that
most teenagers with Down syndrome learn to carry out this behaviour, only in
private.[13]
In order to stop a child from touching him or herself in public, one should not
draw attention to the act by telling the child off, otherwise the behaviour may
be repeated as the child has rewarded for his or her actions through attention
and verbal interaction. It may be enough to simply make sure that the child has
something else to do, e.g. distract them redirect their attention to something
else. However, the child or young person may also need some overt training about
public and private behaviour. They need to learn that touching themselves is a
private behaviour. Family and cultural norms will prevail with regard to where
this behaviour is or is not appropriate, i.e. only in the bedroom and/or
bathroom with the door shut. Once it is felt that the child understands the
words public and private, these words could be used as a prompt to remind the
child, should they start to touch themselves in public, e.g. one should calmly
and systematically say something along the lines of "hands away please, remember
that's private". Social interaction including eye contact should then be
withdrawn for a minute or so and then the child should be welcomed back into the
interaction without referring to the behaviour, e.g. "where were we, ah, I
remember…". Whatever the strategy employed, it is essential that everyone caring
for and working with the child or young person uses it with consistency.
Social stories
Teaching methods such as the use of social stories may be helpful for training
in many areas. This technique involves regular reading of personal books with
illustrations or photographs to teach children about all sorts of social
situations and the associated socially acceptable behaviours. Social stories may
provide a useful way of teaching children and young people with Down syndrome
about a variety of aspects included in sex and relationships education, e.g.
friendship, bullying, acceptable public behaviour and touch, personal hygiene,
periods or who to talk to if you are sad or scared. In terms of using the books
to change behaviour, the story should introduce the behaviour and then outline
the social outcomes for the child if they show socially acceptable behaviour.
Please see
www.thegraycenter.org/ for more information about
the design and use social stories. It may also be useful to support the bookwork
with activities such as encouraging the child to act out the story with dolls or
puppets or for older children to make a photo-story using pictures of characters
from soap operas cut from magazines. Older children may enjoy role-playing
situations that have been introduced in this way.
Social learning
It is important to note that children with Down syndrome are particularly
perceptive to non-verbal social cues and emotional tone. Therefore, the way in
which certain situations and questions are responded to is very important in
shaping the child's attitudes. For example, talking openly about body parts and
using accurate language that is suited to the child's level of comprehension
will help the child to understand more about their own body and therefore
prepare them better to understand body changes at puberty. Parents should aim to
foster an atmosphere in the family of openness, acceptance and respect whereby
children's questions will be valued and answered. Also, modeling appropriate
public and private behaviour will be helpful. Children with Down syndrome are
excellent social learners, that is, they learn well from observation and
imitation. This means concepts such as privacy can be taught through modeling,
e.g. wearing dressing gowns, getting changed with the door closed, pulling the
shower curtain across, etc. In some households, mothers and/or older sisters may
feel comfortable to model the necessary sequence of behaviours involved with
changing a sanitary towel or tampon.
Learning the language
Children with Down syndrome experience the most significant delays in the area
of speech and language, with speech production commonly lagging behind language
comprehension. They are likely to need focused teaching work to help them
develop a vocabulary for thinking about emotions and their bodies. Just as you
would teach the names of other parts of the body, it is important to teach the
'correct' terms for male and female genitals. This is important for several
reasons. Openly talking about and naming these body parts will help children
develop further awareness and a sense of ownership, pride and respect for their
bodies and those of other people. Having a label for each part of the body,
including the genitals, shows the child that they are permitted to discuss them
when necessary and gives them a language with which to do so and with which they
will be understood.[11] Also, an accurate language for describing the body is
important with regard to child protection issues[14] and personal health and
hygiene. The age at which it is appropriate to introduce this vocabulary will
depend on the individual's progress in developing his or her receptive
vocabulary. For example teaching the words 'vulva' or 'penis' will not be
appropriate for example, if the child cannot yet identify his or her shoulder or
knee. These new words can be taught as you would teach any other new vocabulary,
i.e. through matching, selecting and naming activities with pictures (outline
drawings) and printed words. You could try putting printed word cards with the
names of a wide variety of body parts into a bag and asking the child to pick
one at a time and stick them onto cut-out pictures of men and women, to show
that he or she understands which body parts are the same for men and women and
which parts are different.
For children who have made good use of signs to support their vocabulary
development, it is possible to acquire PSHE curriculum-specific signs from
organisations such as The Makaton Vocabulary Development Project (see
www.makaton.org) and Signalong (www.signalong.org.uk/)
Growing up
Teenage boys and girls with Down syndrome experience the physical and emotional
changes of puberty at approximately the same age as their typically developing
peers.[2] Melburg Schwier and Hingsburger describe how these changes may be
particularly difficult if the young person has not been prepared for them in
advance, if their parents feel awkward discussing various issues with them and
if their advances towards others are rejected.[2] The limited research in this
area with teenagers with Down syndrome suggests that most teenagers do not
experience significant difficulties at this time and for many the transition
from childhood to adulthood will be smooth, with families describing a range of
positive and socially-desirable personality traits. However, for some families
this can be a difficult time, leading to changes in the individual's behaviour
and the possibility of more severe adjustment difficulties, which can be
stressful to the family. [13]
Advance preparation generally helps to take some of the stress out of most
things and adolescence is no exception! However, the concept of time and, in
particular, the future may be particularly difficult for some youngsters with
Down syndrome and therefore careful thought and preparation for education in
this area may be necessary. It may be helpful to focus on the present and
discuss the issues in the context of stories and scenarios involving characters
who are experiencing changes 'at the moment' rather than saying this will happen
to you 'some time in the future'. The discussion could then move on to look at
the similarities between the character and the child or young person with Down
syndrome to help him or her to make the connection between the characters and
him or herself. Also, photographic timelines showing how the child has changed
since they were an infant may be helpful to give an idea of what has past. This
timeline could be compared to a timeline for a familiar person of the same sex
who is older than the child to show them how their life may continue for them in
the future.
Independence
One of the major factors determining our happiness is our ability to feel in
control, that we are responsible for things that happen in our lives. This can
be difficult for people with disabilities who may be more dependent upon others
and be familiar with choices being made for them. Fostering a sense of
self-worth and independence is therefore of critical importance to the future
quality of life of people with Down syndrome and this is particularly important
during adolescence when young people may be developing an awareness of their
limitations in comparison with their typically developing peers and siblings.
Discussion of personal hygiene and appearance, buying clothes, toiletries and
cosmetics can be a good starting point for making choices, looking and feeling
good. Small decisions such as which deodorant to buy from a choice of two, will
pave the way for making more important decisions and may be equally important in
enhancing self-esteem.
With regard to independence and self-help skills, most girls with Down syndrome
to take care of their personal hygiene needs during their periods,[13] although
some may need more support than others, e.g. reminders about when to change pads
or tampons.
Close relationships
"[She's] a great friend, I've been working with her for a very long time and
she is a great friend. She looks lovely and gorgeous tonight in her dress. I
am very proud to be her partner as well as her friend" – a man with Down
syndrome talking about his partner, as they attended a 'prom' night
together.[5]
Building on the foundation of an understanding of feelings, positive
self-esteem, valuing and caring for our bodies, understanding concepts such as
privacy and appropriate touch, it is now time to consider that young people with
Down syndrome also need direct teaching about sexual relationships including
information about how people can give and gain sexual pleasure, the reasons why
people might choose to have sex, the possible consequences of unprotected sex
including unwanted pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections such as HIV and
the options regarding contraception. Parents and teachers may feel that some of
these concepts are 'beyond' some young people with Down syndrome, who they may
consider to be more delayed for example. However, it is crucial to be
open-minded and find creative solutions to these concerns for two very important
reasons. Firstly, young people with Down syndrome are likely to be more advanced
in their social and personal skills than they may be in their speech, language,
and cognitive skills. Also, their physical development is likely to be
age-appropriate implying that they may have sexual desires and wish to have a
physical relationship with their chosen partner. Secondly and sadly, as
mentioned previously, the risk of sexual abuse is higher for people with
intellectual disabilities and therefore it is crucial that they are able to
understand the variety of ways in which people may try to gain sexual arousal
and what they may or may not be consenting to.
"When Patsy and I go out on a date, we talk. We walk around the park most
often. We ate together. We once were little kids. Little buddies together.
Then we grow up and she makes me so proud. Her for me and she is happy.
Patsy is a good personality. If someone tell me I can't have her, can't have
a girlfriend, would explain most often love I feel for her, comes back to me
from her." - A man with Down syndrome talking about his partner Patsy, who
also has Down syndrome.[1]
Useful resources for parents and professionals
Any interested or concerned parent or professional would be hard-pushed to find
a more useful starting point than Sexuality: your sons and daughters with
intellectual disabilities.[2] The authors employ an excellent, accessible style
that blends up-to-date, authoritative information and straight-talking advice
with first-person accounts and questions from parents and individuals with
disabilities. It confronts the reader and compels them to reflect upon his or
her attitudes and values towards sexuality, parenting and disability. Marian
Burke, mum of television actor Chris Burke who has Down syndrome, was certainly
right when she described this book as "a MUST" [2:p.ix] as one could easily read
it from cover-to-cover.
Terri Couwenhoven provides a down-to-earth review of some of the main topic
areas that should be addressed in the early years and childhood including
teaching about the body, hygiene, public and private behaviour, gender
differences, touching (self and others) and socially acceptability in a special
issue of Disability Solutions.[8] She writes from the perspective of both a
parent and a sexuality educator and as such, her article makes entertaining and
informative reading.
Parents may be interested by The Birds and the Bees by Genelle Gordon as this
short book provides a very readable guide to how to talk to young children about
bodies, birth and sex.[15] It offers some invaluable guidance for answering
children's awkward questions and dissipating anxiety surrounding embarrassing
moments in a humorous and down-to-earth manner.
The Family Planning Association have published an excellent workbook for parents
of children with learning disabilities called Talking together…about growing
up.[16] The book provides a comprehensive set of activities and resources
covering topics such as the life cycle, body parts, public and private, keeping
safe, feelings and growing up. It also provides guidance for working in
partnership with the child's school and creating a flexible curriculum that is
appropriate to the child's individual needs. There is also an accompanying book
called Talking together…about sex and relationships, which provides a resource
for schools and parents working with teenagers with learning disabilities.[17]
This book covers the topics of preparation for adulthood, keeping safe,
relationships, sex, making choices and sexual health. Although these books have
been specifically designed for students with learning disabilities, the
activities may still require further differentiation for some pupils. However,
they would provide an excellent starting point.
Books beyond words published by The Royal College of Psychiatrists provides a
comprehensive series of books made up entirely of pictures to teach people with
learning disabilities about topics such as periods, hugging and touching, sexual
health, personal hygiene and sexual abuse. These books may be useful in
providing a storyline, which can then be told using language that is appropriate
to the child's level of comprehension. The pictures may be used to inspire
discussion. The parent or teacher could then write simple, grammatically correct
sentences to support the pictures, based on the individual's naturally occurring
language. The books have been specifically designed for people who find pictures
easier to understand than words, however, it should be remembered that many
people with Down syndrome learn well from reading and therefore appropriate
reading activities may be a useful way to teach new vocabulary and concepts. The
books provide ready-made stories at the end, a summary of the issues raised by
the story for the parent or professional supporting the work and a list of
useful references and resources. It should be noted that these books are about
adults and young people and as such, children may not be able to identify as
easily with the characters. For further details, please see
www.rcpsych.ac.uk/publications/bbw.
Talk to me: A personal development manual for women and girls with Down syndrome
and their parents[11] is an excellent resource published by the Down Syndrome
Association of NSW Inc. Exactly as it says it provides a manual (in the form of
a ring bound folder) that will assist parents in talking to their daughters with
Down syndrome. It contains a section for parents, that is reassuring without
being patronising and a section of activities and information on feelings,
self-esteem, friends and sexuality for parents and daughters to share. Although
the manual has been designed for use with girls and women with Down syndrome,
the section for parents contains much information that would still be relevant
to those with sons and would many of the activities. For details, see
http://www.dsansw.org.au/ where, with certain
provisos, you can download the resource for free. The site also gives
information abut other resources.
You, your body and sex: the DVD has been produced by Life Support Productions
and uses animated characters, Kylie and Jason and some of their friends, to
guide the viewer with a learning disability through topics including personal
hygiene, keeping well (e.g. who to tell should you notice anything unusual),
growing up and puberty, periods, pre-menstrual tension, masturbation,
loneliness, meeting some-one new, appropriate touch, love and sex (mentioning
that this can be with some of a different sex or the same sex), consenting to
sex and how to say 'no', how to respond to unwanted attention and obtaining and
using condoms. Other forms of contraception are not discussed. Each topic is
addressed twice, from a female and male perspective. The language used is simple
and repetitive, whilst the graphics are modern and with enough detail to be
interesting but not distracting. The DVD is targeted more towards teenagers and
young adults and each topic would probably need to be discussed with a carer or
parent. Some of the vocabulary used may be new and would need to additional work
to teach and consolidate meaning. This impressive resource has been carefully
and considerately produced and may provide a useful tool to facilitate further
work or bring together aspects that have been introduced in other ways. For
details see www.lifesupportproductions.co.uk.
As mentioned in our last issue of Down Syndrome News and Update, delegates at
the World Congress in Singapore were introduced to a new resource published by
The Down Syndrome Society of South Australia. Right to know is a teaching
programme consisting of three modules on friendship, sexuality and personal
safety. The modules cover all of the topic areas mentioned in this article and
more. At present we do not have a copy of the materials in order to provide a
comprehensive review; however Dr. Jo Nye and Professor Buckley who attended the
Singapore conference agree that these materials may provide an extremely
comprehensive addition to the existing materials available to support SRE for
children, adolescents and adults with Down syndrome. We hope to review this
programme in a future issue of Down Syndrome News and Update. For further
information, see
http://www.downssa.asn.au/resources/catalogue The Canadian Down Syndrome
Society have also published a series of booklets on a variety of aspects of
sexuality entitled "Sexuality, Relationships and Me" which can be ordered from
www.cdss.ca/ along with a selection of other resources.
It is also possible to purchase differentiated personal, social and health
education programmes including sex and relationships education from awarding
bodies such as Equals and Asdan. Again, we have not had the opportunity to
review these packages but they may provide a useful starting point for working
with children and young people with Down syndrome. Further information on these
resources can be found at www.equals.co.uk/ and
www.asdan.co.uk.
References
- Melburg Schwier, K. (1994). Couples with intellectual disabilities talk about
living and loving. Woodbine House, Rockville, MD, USA.
- Melburg Schwier, K. and Hingsburger, D. (2000).
Sexuality; Your sons and
daughters with intellectual disabilities. Paul H Brookes Publishing Co.
Maryland, USA.
- Behind closed doors: Preventing sexual abuse against adults with a learning
disability. (2001). Mencap, Respond and Voice UK.
- Kastner, T.A., Nathanson, R.S. and Marchetti, A.G. (1996). Epidemiology of
HIV infection in adults with developmental disabilities. In A. Crocker, H. Cohen
and T. Kastner (Eds.) HIV infection and developmental disability. Baltimore:
Paul Crooks Publishers, pp. 127-139.
- Listen to us – The Down syndrome women's guide for a healthy life (1999). The
Down Syndrome Association of NSW Inc.
- Fanstone, C. and Katrak, Z. (2003). Sexuality and learning disability: A
resource for staff. fpa, London, UK.
- Sex and relationships Education Guidance (2000). DfES publications
- Couwenhoven, T. (2001). Focus: Sexuality Education: Building a foundation of
healthy attitudes. Disability solutions, 4(5), 1-15.
- Ryan, C. (2004). Sexuality. NZDSA Newsletter: Down Syndrome News, 21 (Winter,
Supplement).
- Ingham, R. (1997). The development of an integrated model of sexual conduct
amongst young people. ESRC.
- D'aegher, L., Robinson, P. and Jones, S. (1999).
Talk to me. Down Syndrome
Association of NSW Inc.
- Forum factsheet 12: Effective learning; approaches to teaching sex
education. National Children's Bureau for the Sex Education Forum.
- Buckley, S. and Sacks, B. (2002). An overview of the development of
teenagers with Down syndrome (11-16 years). Down Syndrome Education International,
Portsmouth, UK.
- Forum factsheet 32: Sex and relationships education for children and young
people with learning difficulties. National Children's Bureau for the Sex
Education Forum.
- Gordon, G. (2002). The birds and the bees: How to talk to your young
children about bodies, birth and sex. Random House, Auckland, New Zealand.
- Scott, L. and Kerr-Edwards, L. (1999). Talking together…about growing up. A
workbook for parents of children with learning disabilities. fpa, London, UK.
- Kerr-Edwards, L. and Scott, L. (2003).
Talking together…about sex and
relationships. A practical resource for schools and parents working with young
people with learning disabilities. fpa, London, UK.
Mandy Wood is a psychologist at Down Syndrome Education International. www.downsed.org