Speech, language and communication for individuals with Down syndrome — An overview
Sue Buckley
Children with Down syndrome are usually good communicators. They are keen to interact socially right from infancy but they have to rely on non-verbal skills such as gesture for longer than other children because they usually experience significant speech and language delay. Once they start to talk, they make good use of the speech and language skills that they have for the same range of communicative activities as everyone else, particularly if encouraged to do so by sensitive support from those around them at home, at school and in the community. However, they have specific difficulty with learning grammar and with developing clear speech. Some of the reasons for their difficulties with learning to talk are known and provide pointers to effective intervention strategies. Researchers and practitioners worldwide now agree on the principles for effective intervention. Since speech and language skills are central to the development of mental abilities such as thinking, reasoning and remembering as well as to social inclusion, it is essential that speech and language is a focus for parents, teachers and therapists from infancy through to adult life. This overview covers development from birth to teenage years, and to understand the speech and language needs of primary and secondary age children, teachers and parents are encouraged to read the whole overview as the children's difficulties have their roots in the preschool years.
Buckley SJ. Speech, language and communication for individuals with Down syndrome — An overview. Down Syndrome Issues and Information. 2000.
doi:10.3104/9781903806005
Individuals with Down syndrome have specific speech
and language impairments
- Their speech and language skills are significantly delayed - more delayed
than non-verbal abilities
- Research has identified a specific profile of speech and language delays
and difficulties associated with Down syndrome
- Recent research has also identified some of the reasons for these delays
and difficulties
- The key principles for effective interventions are agreed by experts
worldwide
- Speech and language skills underpin social and cognitive (mental) development,
therefore affecting all aspects of development
- Improving the speech and language skills of individuals with Down syndrome
will improve all aspects of their development and their quality of life
- Activities to improve speech and language skills can be implemented
by parents, therapists and teachers from birth through to adult life
Introduction
Speech and language skills are an area of particular difficulty
for most children and adolescents with Down syndrome, even though they are keen
to communicate right from infancy and usually have strengths in non-verbal communication
skills such as gesture and sign. Spoken language skills are usually delayed relative
to the children's non-verbal ability and this suggests a profile of specific language
impairment. This should be a focus for targeted and intensive intervention throughout
infancy and childhood, as it is in other language impaired children who show a gap
between verbal and non-verbal abilities.
There has been a considerable amount of research effort
over the past thirty years focused on understanding the speech and language profile
associated with Down syndrome. In the last ten years there have been many important
papers,[1-7] book chapters[8-21]
and books[22-24] published on speech and language
development in individuals with Down syndrome, and the reader wishing to read the
literature in more detail is advised to consult these. These publications have all
contributed to an increased understanding of the language learning needs of children
with Down syndrome. There is now considerable agreement among the experts on the
principles which should guide effective interventions.[1,4,9-12,24-27]
This module explains speech and language development,
highlighting the key findings from research into
- the processes and influences on speech and language
development in typically developing children
- the specific speech and language difficulties of children
with Down syndrome and their possible causes
- effective interventions
This module should be read before using the accompanying
practical modules.
Speech and language skills are central to social
interaction
- Controlling your world - asking for things, expressing discomfort
- Understanding what is happening around you
- Making friends
- Playing together
- Discussing past and future events
- Sharing worries, joys and new experiences
The importance of learning to talk
Learning to talk is the most important thing that children
do. It is central to all other aspects of their development. It is critically important
for social and emotional development and for the development of cognitive or mental
abilities. This is a theme that will be explained and reinforced as the module develops.
Speech and language skills are central to social interaction
Being able to talk allows children to gain control over
their social and emotional world. Talking enables children to ask for what they
want, to share experiences, to understand what is about to happen, and to express
themselves when they are hurt or upset. In short, talking enables children to relate
to others.
By the preschool years, being able to communicate enables
children to play together, to share and to learn together. In school and throughout
life, communication underpins the development of friendships, the sharing of experiences,
supporting one another, and negotiating our way through the world - shopping, travelling
and working.
Speech and language skills are central to mental
ability
- Words for knowledge
- Words for thinking
- Words for reasoning
- Words for remembering
- Words for communicating
Being able to talk also underpins the development of mental
abilities
It is important to note that word learning begins in the
first year of life and continues to old age. Words are knowledge. Each new word
learned is a concept learned and the rate at which words are learned reflects the
rate at which we are gaining knowledge about our world. As language skills develop,
words become a tool for thinking. Once children begin to string words together,
words take over as the most powerful way to think and reason and remember - we do
these things most often as silent speech in our heads.
The human brain has clearly evolved to be very efficient
at developing spoken language and using language as a tool for other mental processes,
such as working memory.
Working memory is the short-term memory system
that supports the initial processing of incoming spoken and visual information as
well as current mental activities such as reading text or adding sums. It is typically
a speech-based system and its efficiency increases as children's speech processing
and speech production abilities improve. Speech and language skills also influence,
and are influenced by, progress in reading skills.
In summary, talking underpins our mental development and
our ability to interact with the world around us. Talking is not the only way to
communicate and we all use many non-verbal means to express ourselves in addition
to words, however words are the most powerful form of communication for social life
and for learning.
This module focuses on the development of spoken language
as almost all individuals with Down syndrome will use speech as their main mode
of communication after five years of age. Signs may be used as a bridge to teaching
spoken language skills but these signs should be 'keyword' signs used to augment
spoken words, they are not taught as an alternative language. Signs may continue
to be helpful throughout life for many individuals with Down syndrome to support
their spoken language, as their speech often remains difficult to understand.
The skills and knowledge needed for talking
A complex range of knowledge and skills interact to give us our ability to
communicate by talking. These can be considered under three main headings -
interactive communication skills, spoken language knowledge and speaking. Spoken
language knowledge can be further subdivided into vocabulary and grammar. In
Table 1 the terms that professionals may use for these different aspects of
talking are included in brackets.
Table 1. The skills
and knowledge needed for talking
| Interaction |
Spoken language knowledge |
Speaking |
| Non-verbal skills |
Vocabulary |
Grammar |
Speech/motor skills |
Smiling, eye-contact, taking turns, initiating
a conversation, maintaining the topic
Body language
Facial expressions
(pragmatics and discourse skills) |
Building a dictionary of single words and their
meanings (lexicon and semantics) |
Learning the word ending rules for plurals,
tenses and word order rules for questions, negatives, (morphology and syntax) |
Learning to make speech sounds and to produce
clear words with correct stress and intonation (articulation, phonology
and prosody) |
At any age, children's progress in all areas (i.e. in
interactive communication skills, vocabulary knowledge, grammar knowledge and speech
skills) always need to be considered. These skills are acquired over a period of
years from infancy through primary and secondary school and a great deal is known
about the processes that influence their development in typically developing children.
Table 2. The typical
timetable for learning to talk
| Age |
Communication |
Vocabulary |
Grammar |
Speech |
| Infants (0-12 months) |
Crying
Eye-contact
Smiling
Listening/looking
Vocalising - coos
Turn taking
Joint attention
Gestures |
Understanding some words |
|
Babble
Babble tuned to native language |
| 12-24 months |
Conveying an increasing number of meanings in
words |
Beginning to say words
First 10 words
First 50 - 100 words |
Begin saying two words together |
Initial consonants and vowels developing
Words not very clear/intelligible |
| 24-36 months |
Initiating conversations |
300 words
Rate of word learning increases (25 words per month) |
Three and four key words together
'telegraphic' sentences
Grammar begins |
Consonant, vowel and word production improve
in accuracy |
| 36-60 months |
Repairing conversations when not understood |
Vocabulary learning continues to accelerate |
Increasingly correct sentences |
Consonant and vowel production continue to improve
in accuracy |
| 5-7 years |
Learning to continue narratives,
Taking part in longer topic related conversations
Telling stories
Requesting clarifications - . What?, Where? |
Average vocabulary of about 2000 words at 5
years |
Correct syntax being mastered
More difficult prepositions�
above, below,
conjunctions - because,
comparatives - 'longer than' |
Blends improve
Speech intelligible |
| 7-16 |
Developing social use of language further -
social small talk
Taking account of listener's knowledge - know how to provide appropriate
amounts of information for person or social situation
Give longer explanations or instructions
Telling jokes
Recounting experiences
Discussing attitudes and beliefs, with rationales |
From 7 years 3000 new words learned each year
50,000 words or more at 16 years |
Grammar steadily extended to include passives
and other features such as
'not only� but also'
'however', 'therefore'
Many of these features are learned and used first in reading and writing
and then in speaking |
Speech rate and speech clarity continue to improve,
influenced by reading |
Comprehension and production of language
- Children understand spoken language before they use it
- Therefore, children's understanding of language should be assessed separately
from their spoken language skills
- Spoken language skills are referred to as production or expressive language
skills by researchers and speech and language therapists
- Understanding of language is referred to as comprehension or receptive
language knowledge
Table 2 provides a guide to the
way in which progress in each area relates to ages and to stages of development
in typically developing children. The table describes the milestones for children's
spoken language skills in each area. Most children will understand these actions,
words and grammar in everyday communication earlier than they are able to use them
in their speech. Therefore, when assessing children's language skills, production
and comprehension of vocabulary and grammar are assessed separately.
The range of skills required for individuals with Down
syndrome to communicate are no different from the range of skills employed by anyone
else. Unfortunately, a number of difficulties with the skills required for speech
and language are associated with Down syndrome. Promoting these skills and helping
children with Down syndrome to overcome these difficulties is clearly fundamental
for all aspects of their social and mental development. The way in which each of
the skills develop in non-disabled children is discussed in the following section
to set the scene for understanding the difficulties faced by children with Down
syndrome and ways in which they may be reduced or overcome.
Learning to talk is an everyday activity
- Children learn to talk in everyday interactions
- Children learn to talk because they want to communicate
- Communicating in gestures leads to talking
- Communicating in words leads to sentences
Learning to talk is an everyday activity
Children learn to talk because they want to communicate.
Communicating with gestures in infancy leads to communicating with words and sentences.
Children learn to talk as they take part in all the ordinary, everyday communication
that they experience during their waking hours. The quality and quantity of the
language that they experience as they are talked to each day influences the rate
at which children progress with learning to talk. [28-30]
Parent's talk styles influence children's progress
Parent's influence on child talk
- Using question forms and explanations rather than orders was better:
- Parents who say ''Move'' or ''shut-up'' have children who say the same
- Parents who say ''Can you move your things so that I can lay the table
for lunch'' have children who give explanations and can ask questions.
- Similar contrasts can be seen in ''Could you pick up your toys please?''
rather than ''Pick up your toys'' or ''Do you think that you need to go
and look in your bedroom'' rather than ''You need to go''... Or worse still
''Go and look in your bedroom''.
Using choices and explanations was better:
- ''Do you want to do it yourself or with my help?''
- ''Can you eat up your carrot? - it is good for you. You did really well
with your sandwich. Lets finish the carrot because then we can have the
little boxes of raisins that Grandma brought''
Adapted from Hart and Risley [30
p.149]
Longitudinal research by Hart and Risley [29,30]
indicates that the amount and quality of talk that typically developing babies are
exposed to each day varies considerably in different homes. The more children were
talked to, the faster they expanded their vocabulary. The children who were talked
to the most had the highest Verbal IQ scores at 4 years, also supporting this author's
argument that language learning is fundamental to the development of cognitive skills
or mental abilities.
Parents who were more effective language teachers
- They talked to their children frequently
- They tried to be positive
- They told children about things
- They gave children choices
- They listened to their children
Adapted from Hart and Risley [30
p.149]
Verbal IQ was specifically influenced by the amount that
parents participated in activities with their children and included their children
in conversation as they went about daily chores, by the total amount of words and
range of different words that parents used with their children, by parent's responsiveness
to their children's attempts to initiate communications and by the way in which
parents responded. Positive response styles included extensions and expansions of
the child's utterance, which help to teach grammar. They also included a style which
asked, rather than told, children to do things.
The link between language learning and intelligence
''A vocabulary growth curve provides a direct and
continuous measure of a child's intellectual functioning ... The growth of the
vocabulary in use directly reflects the increasing complexity of symbols a child
learns to manipulate relative to everyday experience. We did not need to infer
cognitive growth from monitoring a child's periodic performance on a small set
of standardised test items: we could measure learning as it was happening''
- Hart and Risley[30, p.16]
Emotional style turned out to be particularly important
as the children of parents who regularly used a negative style, that is, saying
''no'', criticising the child and prohibiting activities made much slower progress
with their language development than the children of parents who regularly had a
positive style and praised, encouraged and conveyed delight at their children's
efforts. Children also learned to talk like their parents, using orders and being
negative and bossy in style or using explanations and asking politely, depending
on parent style.
Play activities and book reading
Studies have shown that, while including children in conversations
throughout the day is important, the language that parents use when joining in toy
play activities and reading books with children provides the richest sources of
language experience for their children.
Children learn, and later use, the language
that has been addressed to them in specific contexts repeatedly, as is illustrated
by the early use of 'bye-bye', 'all gone', 'more' and by the learning of responses
in games and from singing action or nursery rhymes. Learning from regular repetition
in social situations and from games is probably even more important for children
with language learning difficulties.
Influences on the rate at which a child learns to
talk
- How much the child is talked to
- The quality and quantity of talk
- The quality and quantity of social experience with peers
- Being read to and learning to read
Social learning with other children
As children move beyond the family to preschool and school
settings, the opportunities to communicate with a wide range of partners develop.
The quality and quantity of these social opportunities, particularly with peers,
will also influence all aspects of speech and language development.